The Competitive Runner
Home > Polar S625X Review, Page 2 of 5 Saturday, July 31 , 2010 - 06:44











Save at Road Runner Sports
Review: Polar S625X, Page 2 of 5

Save at Road Runner Sports

Let's go for a run!

Once you have calibrated the S625X and set all your personal options, it is time to head out for a run. After using the S625X, you will quickly realize how much information it can display. This is both good and bad. It is good because you can display almost anything you could want to see while running. It is bad because the monitor only has room to display three data elements, and one of those will only display heart rate data. That leaves only two spots on the S625X for other data elements. If you want to look at something that is not currently displayed you need to scroll through all the available elements to show what you want to see. This can be somewhat frustrating if you are running hard. The variables that you can display include distance, altitude, ascent, time of day, lap time, run time, pace, calories burned, trip distance, speed, average speed, and maximum speed. Most runners have a preference of viewing either pace, (minutes per mile or minutes per kilometer) or speed (miles per hour or kilometers per hour). People rarely need both. If a runners preference could be set, then the Polar could exclude variables the runner does not care to see.

With all these data elements, you would think that none would be missing, but some are. Polar should include cumulative pace, cumulative lap pace, lap distance, and cadence as possible display options.

Polar should also allow the area that currently displays only heart rate data to display other information. There are times, for example, when a runner might want to see run distance, pace, and lap time. With the Polar this is not possible, because although the S625X has a place to display three fields of information, one of those is locked on to heart rate information.

Rather that providing buttons that cycle through all the various readings, Polar should allow the user to set up a variety of screens. If the user could define three or four screens, then they need only cycle through those three screens. It would be nice, for example, to be able to set up a "now" screen that shows current HR, current pace, and cumulative distance. A second screen could show lap distance, lap pace, and lap HR. A third screen could then display altitude, total time, and time of day. These are just examples of what one runner might like. Other users should be able to define other screens with the variables they find useful. The right side buttons could then be used to go back and forth between screens. This would be much more efficient than the one-way cycling of variables that is now required and is similar to the well designed system used by Garmin in their Forerunners.

When you set up your exercise sets you can define three heart rate limits. For example, you may want to set limits of 145-159 as your range for aerobic training, 160-169 for anaerobic threshold training, and 170-175 for VO2 max training. The polar allows you to do this. Once you have these ranges set up, you can select the range in which you want to train and the S625X will tell you if you are within, above, or below that range. You can start out a run in range 1, move to range 2 for some tempo work, move to range 3 for some VO2 max training, and then back to range 1 for your cool down. You move from one HR limit to the next by holding down the upper-right button for a couple of seconds.

You should note, however, that in the Polar environment heart rate limits are different than heart rate training zones. The former is built into the S625X receiver and its primary purpose is to alert users when they are outside defined ranges. The latter is used in the Polar Precision Performance Software (PPP) only and can be used to show how much time or how many miles was spent in your various HR training zones. Many athletes monitor how much time they spend in various training zones because it helps them understand their workload better than simply looking at hours or miles run. Unfortunately, this functionality, the tracking of time spent in various zones, is a feature of the PPP software only. This is unfortunate since many people may not choose to use the PPP software.

You can simulate the functionality of HR zones in your HRM, without using PPP, by using the HR limits feature, but this is quite clunky. Polar should build HR zone functionality into the HRM itself so that runners can track time spent in each zone, both for the current run and over time, without using PPP.

The signals sent by the WearLink are coded, so your S625X will pick up signals from only your WearLink. If you have ever run in a group or race where other people are wearing HRMs and you were not using a coded transmitter and receiver, then you will know that in such a situation you can not trust the heart rate displayed by your receiver. The WearLink was tested during the 2005 Boston Marathon (without the foot pod) and gave reliable heart rate readings throughout the race, even though many other surrounding people were wearing HR monitors.

Foot pods transmission is not coded, however. This could lead to erroneous readings, but we were not able to verify this.

One other note about the foot pod. Some runners may find that they do not like its feel. It is not heavy, but if the top of your foot is bony and you wear shoes with thin tongues, then you may find the foot pod is uncomfortable. Minimalists runners who spend much of their training wearing light weight trainers or racing flats may not be able to wear the foot pod. Barefoot runners...well, nevermind.

  [top]

< < Next Page [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] Next Page > >


Save at Road Runner Sports

Running shoes at Zappos
Copyright © 2002-2008 Nuovo Data Services, Inc. All rights reserved.
PO Box 637, Shelburne, VT 05482
victor@competitiverunner.com
All other copyrights are reserved by their respective holders.
By using competitiverunner.com, you agree to our terms and conditions.